Note: After a brief struggle with my conscience, the names in this true story have all been changed.
Todd knocked on our door and asked if I had a minute — which was a little weird since he had a crush on my roommate, not me. But I sat down anyway, giving him about half of my attention.
Todd started asking questions about me and my boyfriend Jim. We had dated freshman year and started up again three years later. Todd asked why. We had just returned from a weekend trip to visit my grandparents. Todd asked where and for how long. We studied together at the library. Todd asked which floor.
Jim had recently given me a peek at an engagement ring and asked if I liked the style (I hadn’t, but the prospect was thrilling). Todd asked what the ring looked like.
So annoying — I could see why my roommate wasn't very interested in Todd.
It got even worse when he started asking about Kelsey. Yes, I knew that she had been engaged to Jim at one point. Her mental stability was in question, so she, poor girl, had threatened to commit suicide when Jim broke it off. Understandably, he was still in periodic contact with her so that she never followed through with her threat.
I told Todd that Jim (short for James) had a big heart, which was one of the reasons I had fallen in love with him.
Todd leaned forward and took a deep breath, clearly uncomfortable. I clued in (finally) and gave him my full attention.
"Did you know that I work with Kelsey?"
Todd was a good listener. So, like me, Kelsey told him all about her love life. It seemed that she was practically engaged to this amazing guy named Jamie. He even had the ring she had picked out and was waiting for the perfect moment to officially propose.
Kelsey, Todd explained nervously, had been furious when Jamie had taken off with an old girlfriend to visit her grandparents. Kelsey had only been appeased after Jamie explained how his ex couldn't afford the gas money — poor girl — so he had generously offered to help drive and pay for the trip.
Kelsey told Todd that Jamie (short for James) had a big heart, which was one of the reasons she had fallen in love with him.
I stared at Todd, trying to register what he was telling me. When it eventually sank in, I felt physically ill.
Just before crawling into bed that night, I called Jim to say that I couldn't see him that weekend and hung up. I knew for a fact that if I had talked to him for even a few more minutes, he would have explained away everything I had just heard.
And I would have let myself believe him.
Falling out of love — no matter how much I wanted to — wasn’t easy.
Curling up into a ball and pulling the covers over my head, I prayed that morning would never come.
When it did, I forced myself through my daily routine of classes and work and discovered there are times when you have to remind yourself to breathe.
I had some figuring out to do, so I reluctantly called Jim's best friend (whom I had known since freshman year). He assured me that Jim was head over heels in love with me and that Kelsey was not only a raving lunatic but a lying one as well.
With this fantastic news, I told myself I could now stop all this nonsense. Except that, deep down, I knew I needed to dig further.
My next call was to Jim's sister, who regaled me with stories about Jim lying since he was a kid. I listened to her in disbelief, thinking she must be joking.
My third call scared me beyond words. I knew I had to contact Kelsey (even if she was nuts) for me to see things clearly. But seriously, how?
Serendipity, it turned out.
For the first time, on a campus with a student body of roughly 30,000, Kelsey and I crossed the same street, at the same time, going in opposite directions. I recognized this as the non-coincidental gift that it was and knew I had to take it.
But I was still terrified and waited until the last possible second to yell across the intersection, “Kelsey!”
She turned, looked at me and waited.
"We need to talk."
After a long pause, she agreed.
We set up a time and place.
Knocking on her door took more guts than I thought I had. During the silence that followed, Kelsey and I really saw each other for the first time.
And then we talked for hours.
Quite stellar at multitasking, James had been juggling two serious relationships along with a full load of classes and a job. After comparing our calendars, we estimated that he had been getting two or three hours of sleep at night. At most.
But he hadn’t figured my perfume into the equation. James would often kiss me goodbye on one floor of the library, walk downstairs, and kiss Kelsey hello. The scent of perfume, it turns out, doesn’t dissipate in a mere three flights of stairs. Kelsey recognized my perfume almost immediately; she had recently told James that his new cologne was a little feminine.
Our chat was no walk in the park. We cried. We screamed. We cried some more. But we also laughed. Ironically, we were each talking to the only other person on the planet who could understand — almost perfectly — what the other one was going through.
Regrettably for James, he had chosen the wrong two girls to mess with. We were strong, we had been wronged, and James — poor guy — was about to hear us roar, in a manner of speaking.
The knock at James' door came the next morning at 9 a.m. When his roommate — who had seen all of our comings and goings without ever saying a word — opened the door and saw both of us, his eyes visibly popped.
We asked to speak with James. The roommate obliged by walking down the hall (with a spring in his step, I might add) to James’ bedroom. We heard the conversation.
"James! Kelsey … and Susie … are here to see you."
"Both of them?"
The voices quieted. The roommate reappeared.
"He's still sleeping."
We raised our eyebrows.
Delighted, he yelled down the hall, "They say they'll wait!"
We knew James would consider all possible escape routes. Having already considered said routes, we were aware of his dilemma. He had nowhere to run, nowhere to hide, and we all knew it.
Approximately two lifetimes later, James swaggered into the room wearing sweats and a desperate smirk.
"So … you found out."
Kelsey and I had made a pact that there would be no yelling or crying (on our parts, in any case). So we simply presented him with the huge pile of incriminating evidence and waited for a response.
James oozed with charisma — Kelsey and I had both fallen for it. And he was super awesome when it came to deceit. But sweet talk or lie his way out of this one? He didn’t even try. So in the end, when the charisma and lies were pulled out from under him, the only thing left was that smirk.
It was almost a pity, really. All that time and money spent — not to mention so much lost sleep — only to lose us both with one slam of the door.
That’s pretty much the end of the story — if you don’t count the few months of crying and not eating much and cutting my long hair that James had liked so much.
When I tell this story to my daughters, I observe their reactions. And in the event that they’ve been too caught up in all its high drama to recognize the lessons contained therein — which is often the case — I try to spell them out.
First off, best friends aren’t always your most reliable source of information about a guy.
Secondly, charisma and sweet talk are terribly overrated.
Finally and most importantly, figure out who the guy really is. If honesty isn’t one of his core character traits, slam the door and move on.
It’ll be worth the temporary heartbreak.
Susie Boyce is a freelance writer based in Highland Village. Read her column each month in The Cross Timbers Gazette. Contact Boyce at
or visit her website at www.seriousmomsense.com