I was disappointed in the square 16" pizza from Costco. It looks better than it tastes. I would have to give it a rating between 2 (fair) and 3 (good). At least it was relatively cheap at $7.99! Because it was cheap, I'd probably buy it again at some point in the future even though it didn't quite make it to 3 smileys. I think if it had a better crust it could get a 3 or 3.5.
Rating 2.5 smileys (out of 5):